You are here

Mexico, 5/1/2015

Estimado Señor Presidente
Enrique Peña Nieto
President of the Republic of Mexico

Estimada Señora Procuradora
Arely Gómez González
Attorney General of Mexico

Dear Sir and Madam:

We are very concerned about the continued detention of Pedro Celestino Canché Herrera, an independent Mayan journalist, who has been in prison since August 30, 2014 in the town of Felipe Carrillo Puerto in the state of Quintana Roo.

He was arrested for allegedly sabotaging the local water supply. The local manager of the Quintana Roo State water and sewage commission accused Canché of personally directing protesters to block access to the commission’s headquarters during a demonstration on August 11, 2014 against increased water bills in the state. Canché denied the allegations and said he had witnesses and evidence that placed him in the city of Cancún on August 11.

Canché has reported on and advocated for many years for local Mayan causes, worked in small local publications, and was an important source for journalists working in the region. A few days before his arrest, he published photos of local protests against water tariff hikes and a video in which he was critical of the governor’s policies toward the Mayan population.

In February, Reynaldo Piñón Rangel, the Sixth District Judge of Quintana Roo, ruled that Canché’s right to due process had been violated. He said there was no conclusive evidence that sabotagehad occurred or that Canché was even present on the days that the events described in the charges were alleged to have happened.  However, the judge did not release Canché. He ordered the lower court judge, who had upheld a previous challenge to Canche’s imprisonment, to review the case again. Canché’s lawyer and the state water commission have both appealed the ruling. The proceedings are ongoing.

During the past decade violence tied to organized crime has made Mexico one of the most dangerous countries in the world for the press. In this context of an already restricted press freedom climate, a critical journalist should not face retaliation and imprisonment by state authorities for reporting on issues of public interest.

Therefore, we strongly urge that you

  • immediately withdraw all charges against Canché because of the arbitrary nature of the proceedings against him and release him from prison;
  • stop using the judicial system to criminalize critical journalists.


Brian J. Stefan Szittai       Christine Stonebraker-Martinez